i'd take both, but on the PC, xbox just sux with their big and small controls......+ graphics on the pc are usually better.
and its no good playin an fps game on such controls(either ps2 or xbox, tho i know there's a kb/mouse for xbox).
anywayz i vote for GTA SA(i still do own a ps2, MK6 playin online rox:P) as i've liked it better than halo(past versions), tho halo is good, gta just rox over it.
it is all my opinion, and either of these games are not in same place to debate on.
1993 nissan 240sx hatchback(stock) <<drifter, straight liner, road courser
"Horsepower is the force that determines how fast you hit the wall. Torque is the force that determines how far you take the wall with you after you hit it."
"Horsepower sells cars, torque wins races" - Carroll Shelby
"Real cars don't make power at the front wheels....they lift them."