Finally settled on a set of these.
Michelin Primacy MXV4
Update- The tires came on Friday, my dad installed them. I drove the Subaru briefly today, and although they were better than the tires they replaced (they were so worn parts of the steel belts were showing), I seem to liked the Bridgestone G019s more. Too bad he wanted them to be rotatable, or else we would have gotten another set of Bridgestones.